![]() |
Culpepper Cattle Co. (The) (Blu-ray)
[Blu-ray]
Blu-ray B - United Kingdom - Signal One Entertainment Review written by and copyright: Paul Lewis (2nd February 2017). |
The Film
![]() ![]() Made during the early 1970s, Dick Richards’ The Culpepper Cattle Co. (1972) is a clear example of a revisionist Western; it is a film that openly questions the mythologising of classic film Westerns via its depiction of the hardships of life in the West. Like a number of other revisionist Westerns of the era – for example, Sam Peckinpah’s Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid (1973) or Frank Perry’s Doc (1971, also recently released on Blu-ray by Signal One Entertainment and reviewed by us here) - The Culpepper Cattle Co. seeks authenticity in its mise-en-scène. The characters’ costumes are dirty, their environments worn and looking ‘lived-in’. The actors aren’t the glamorous stars of previous Hollywood Westerns; their faces look as ‘lived-in’ as their clothes. It’s an open challenge to the sanitised representation of the West that, via a sense of visual and narrative realism (which in the context of these 1970s Westerns was synonymous with an exceptionally bleak worldview), was seen to characterise Hollywood Westerns of previous eras. Writing about The Culpepper Cattle Co. upon its first release in 1972, Judith Crist suggested that the picture ‘looks as if it might have been torn from the pages of an American Heritage history, supplemented by old photos found in a desert ghost-town shack and pieced out with half-memories of incidents reported by aging cowpokes’ (Crist, 1972: 56). The film itself begins with such photographs, the opening titles playing out over sepia-tinted photographs that have the look of authentic period portraits of settler and cowboys. (Interestingly, Dick Richards began his career as a stills photographer.) Similar montages of still photographs were featured in the opening credits sequences of Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (George Roy Hill, 1969) and the later Posse (Mario Van Peebles, 1993). ![]() His numbers dwindling, Culpepper orders Ben to ride to a nearby town, Castigo, and there enlist the help of Russ Caldwell (Geoffrey Lewis). On his way to Castigo, Ben stops to take a shit and two fur trappers hold him at gunpoint, taking Ben’s horse and his gun. Ben walks the rest of the way to the town and finds Caldwell, who we soon realises is a hired gun rather than a cowboy. Caldwell vows to work for Culpepper, along with Caldwell’s associates Dixie Brick (Bo Hopkins), Missoula (Wayne Sutherlin) and Luke (Luke Askew). On their way back to Culpepper’s cattle drive, Caldwell and the others find the fur trappers and kill them, returning Ben’s horse and gun back to him. When Ben and the others return to Culpepper, Ben volunteers for night watch. Culpepper is doubtful at first but, finding himself short of men willing to perform this duty, gives the boy a chance to fulfill a role other than that of the cook’s ‘Little Mary’. However, during the night rustlers attack Ben and steal a number of Culpepper’s horses. Culpepper and his men ride into a town where they find the thief in a saloon, thanks to Ben’s help. Ben is forced to kill a man in self-defence, and with the aid of Caldwell’s gang Culpepper manages to best the horse thieves. However, back at the camp Caldwell reveals himself to be something of a bully, threatening one of the cowboys to the point that the cowboy leaves the cattle drive rather than become involved in a duel with the seasoned gunslinger. ![]() The cowboys drive the cattle to a small community of settlers, a religious order headed by Nathaniel Green (Anthony James). Green preaches equality, telling Culpepper and his men that ‘We are all brothers and sisters here, all children of God’. Ben is fascinated with Green’s doctrine and listens carefully to Green’s assurance that ‘Here man can live without violence and without bloodshed’. However, Thornton Pierce rides out to the community with his men and confronts Culpepper, also challenging Green: the religious community has, it seemed, settled on land belonging to Thornton Pierce. However, Green tells the landowner that the territory is ‘God’s land’ and he refuses to move the settler group from it. Thornton Pierce promises to return, and when he returns to the site he vows that ‘We’re coming in to blast whatever trespassers is left’. Green asks Culpepper for help in fighting Thornton Pierce’s men, as Green’s community has forsworn violence of any kind. Culpepper refuses, but Ben sees this as a chance to ‘do it right’. ![]() After saying goodbye to his mother, in a poignant and quiet moment in which Ben’s mother’s lack of words underscores her ambivalence about the situation, Ben joins the cattle drive and is given the position of the drive’s ‘Little Mary’ – assistant to the cook. Riding with the cook, Ben tells his new companion ‘I’ve never been up north before’. The cook’s response offers the film’s first challenge to Ben’s romantic ideas about the life of a cowboy: ‘Wait till you get to the desert’, the cook says dryly, ‘Sand scorching your eyeballs. Driving through country that ain’t fit for scavengers. Dry enough to make you drink your own piss’. ‘I guess all I wanna do is punch cows and ride and cowboyin’. There’s nothing better than that’, Ben asserts. ‘Like hell there ain’t’, the cook sneers, ‘Kid, cowboyin’ is something you do when you can’t do nothin’ else’. The cook’s response to Ben’s romanticisation of the life of a cowboy emblematises the film’s depiction of ‘cowboyin’ as a proletarian occupation, a thankless and unromantic lifestyle characterised by wage slavery and unsavoury living and working conditions. As David Lusted says, the film features scenes that focus on ‘workplace harassment and bullying of men and cattle’ (Lusted, 2014: 225). For example, Ben is mocked when his misunderstands one of the cowboy’s command that Ben picket the cowboy’s horse for him: when Ben tries to mount the horse instead of leading it to the picket by its reins, the horse throws Ben, and Ben becomes the subject of much laughter. ![]() ![]() When Ben is attacked by the rustlers whilst on night watch, he is chastised by Culpepper for not shooting the thieves. ‘Why the hell didn’t you shoot them?’, Culpepper asks him demandingly. ‘I wanted to, Mr Culpepper’, Ben says, ‘I sure as hell wanted to’. ‘But you didn’t’, Culpepper responds angrily, ‘Damn stupid kid!’ Culpepper and the others ride into a town where Ben spots one of the thieves in the saloon. Missoula tells Ben to hold his gun on the bartender (‘If he moves, kill ‘im’, he says, in words that echo Pike Bishop’s advice to his crew during the opening heist of The Wild Bunch). Culpepper confronts the thief. Violence follows, with Culpepper’s men executing the thief and his associates in slow-motion (the brutality of the moment underscored by the use of squibs). Ben is faced with his own decision, kill or be killed, when the bartender reaches for a shotgun, and Ben makes the choice to shoot first. With this action, Ben has begun to tread a path of violence from which he can’t return. ‘Is he dead?’, Ben asks, shocked and concerned. ‘Deader’n hell, kid. Deader’n hell’, Dixie Brick answers coolly. ![]() In some ways, in its ultimate epiphany, The Culpepper Cattle Co. feels like the polar opposite to Soldier Blue. Both films culminate in an attack on a small settlement. In Soldier Blue, the climax offers a representation of the Sand Creek massacre, in a sequence that drew parallels between the actions of the militia under the command of Colonel John M Chivington at Sand Creek in 1864 and the atrocities committed by the US Army at My Lai in 1968; in The Culpepper Cattle Co., a similar climax is achieved when the group of religious settlers ask the cowboys to defend them from the landowner Thornton Pierce, who threatens the settlers with the promise of violence if they do not move off his land. (It’s impossible to discuss the film’s major themes without talking about the climax and resolution of the film, and I’ll do so here; first time viewers would do well to skip to the ‘Video’ section of this review if they do not want the story of The Culpepper Cattle Co. to be ‘spoiled’.) ![]() Green attempts to appeal to Culpepper, asking him to stay and fight Thornton Pierce’s men in order to help the settlers: ‘God sent you here to help us’, Green asserts. ‘All you have to do is leave’, Culpepper reminds Green. ‘We cannot’, Green responds. As Culpepper and his group begin to leave, Ben tells them he’s staying: ‘These people, they need some kind of help’, he pleas. ‘You can’t help them’, Culpepper tells him, reminding Ben of his youth and lack of experience in matters of violence, and the fact that he is massively outnumbered by Thornton Pierce’s group. ‘Some things are more important to a man than cattle, Mr Culpepper’, Ben asserts idealistically. ‘Not to me’, Culpepper responds, a true capitalist to the bitter end. Strapping on his gunbelt, Ben makes the decision to stay with the religious group – no matter how far the odds may seem to be stacked against him. The four hired guns begin to ride off with the cattle drive but turn, reflecting on Ben’s decision to stay and fight an enemy that so obviously outnumbers him (and which is much more experienced in both life and violence). After a moment of hesitation, the four gunslingers turn their horses and ride back to the settlers, the heroism of their decision underscored by the use of what Andrew Patrick Nelson calls ‘triumphant music’ (ibid.). The music and the photography reinforce the extent to which these men have made the ‘moral choice’ – an act of interventionism that seems to openly parallel the decision of the US to become involved in the Vietnam War, for example, the settlers seeming to act as a metonym for the South Vietnamese and the gunfighters symbolising the American military. (Much as in Soldier Blue, the Cheyenne inhabitants of Sand Creek metonymically represent the Vietnamese, and the militia that target them are an all too obvious representation of the American military.) ![]() The gunfighters, Ben’s friends, are killed defending a group who will not pick up arms to defend themselves; their brutal end is witnessed by Ben, a young man and relative innocent. After the battle has ended, on the soundtrack we are presented with a rendition of ‘Amazing Grace’. But the moment of heroism is undercut when Green coldly tells Ben that his group will now move on: ‘We’re leavin’’, Green says, ‘Can’t stay on this field of death. The entire valley is soaked with blood’. Ben is shocked by the realisation that his friends have sacrificed their lives for nothing. ‘What about them?’, he cries, indicating towards the corpses of his friends, ‘You’re not gonna just leave ‘em there. You gotta bury them first’. Where Soldier Blue’s depiction of a similar scenario, an assault enacted on a small community, was intended to criticise military might and violence via depicting the brutality of the militia that attack the Native American settlers at Sand Creek, The Culpepper Cattle Co. reserves its scorn for the hypocrisy of the settlers that demand the passing cowboys help defend their land and rights before criticising the violence that has been enacted in their name – suggesting that the defence of such communities may appear to be morally ‘right’ but is ultimately thankless. (Ultimately, Culpepper’s attitude, which at first glance appears dismissive of the settlers, is in retrospect the most logical one.) For her part, Judith Crist commented in her contemporaneous review of the film that the final sequences of the film teach Ben, via ‘his own decision to side with the weak that precipitates the film’s tragic climax, that the weak can betray, that the strong can be shattered and that his last-ditch contention that a cowboy has to be dedicated to something higher than cattle is just another bit of dangerous romanticism’ (Crist, op cit.: 56). ![]()
Video
![]() The presentation offers an incredibly rich level of detail and the structure of 35mm film is preserved by a robust encode. The increase in detail allows the viewer to witness, in one scene, the tear running down Ben’s cheek as a doctor tends to his wounds; this is a detail that was never evident in the film’s previous home video releases. Contrast levels are excellent, with strong, defined midtones and deep, rich blacks offset by balanced highlights. It’s a beautifully shot film, and aside from much of the film being shot at what seems to be magic hour, the light giving a warm glow to the photography, the film features a fair bit of contre-jour photography, silhouettes often framed against a sunrise or sunset; these shots are communicated very nicely here. There’s little damage to the material other than the odd fleck or speck here or there and a notoriously difficult-to-remove vertical line present in a handful of shots, and no harmful digital tinkering evident in the presentation.
Audio
Audio is presented via a LPCM 1.0 mono track. This is rich and deep, with lots of range. It is accompanied by optional English subtitles for the Hard of Hearing; these are accurate and error free.
Extras
The disc includes: ![]() - An audio commentary with actor Bo Hopkins and film historian C Courtney Joyner. The pair discuss the film’s origins, and Hopkins compares the film with his work for Sam Peckinpah. They discuss the film’s aesthetic and the attempts to capture authenticity in both the mise-en-scène and the film’s narrative. They reflect on the similarities between the story of this film and that of the John Wayne Western The Cowboys (Mark Rydell, 1972). The commentary is thorough and enthusiastic, Hopkins and C Courtney Joyner interacting wonderfully throughout. - ‘Black and White in Colour’ (40:46). Here, in a new interview Dick Richards reflects on his career as a commercial photographer and how this evolved. He discusses his work making commercials, which led to his role as the director of The Culpepper Cattle Co. Richards talks about what he hoped to achieve with the film’s aesthetic, shooting a ‘black and white movie in colour’, the casting and the production. He reveals that Peckinpah was one of the film’s fans. (Interestingly, in counterpoint to this, it’s been suggested elsewhere that Sergio Leone was heavily critical of the film.) It’s an excellent, candid and insightful interview. - Location Photography (0:36). These are mostly colour stills (with one monochrome image included) shot during the production of the film. - Promotional Materials (0:20). This gallery includes headshots and group portraits of the actors, along with lobby cards and posters used to promote the picture. - Original Theatrical Trailer (2:56). - Radio Spot (0:30).
Overall
![]() This Blu-ray disc contains a stellar presentation of the main feature that is a huge improvement over previous home video releases of the film. (The previous benchmark was the R1 DVD release of the picture, and Signal One Entertainment’s new Blu-ray leaves that release in the proverbial dust.) The main feature is also accompanied by some superb contextual material, the new interview with Richards offering insight into his approach to the film and the commentary with Bo Hopkins situating the film firmly within the context of both the era and the ways in which the Western genre was developing during that period. This is a superb release that fans of Westerns will find to be essential. References: Crist, Judith, 1972: ‘The Stench of the West’. New York Magazine (24 April, 1972): 56-7 French, Philip, 2011: Westerns: Aspects of a Movie Genre. Manchester Carcanet Film (Revised Edition) Lusted, David, 2014: The Western. London: Routledge Nelson, Andrew Patrick, 2015: Still in the Saddle: The Hollywood Western, 1969-1980. University of Oklahoma Press ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|
|||||
![]() |